The two Democrats vying to become House
majority leader next year are courting Democratic candidates
likely to win in November, hoping to reach out early to those who
may one day have a say in their promotion.Rival Reps. Steny
Hoyer (Md.) and Jack Murtha (Pa.) have been discreetly raising the
issue with candidates, even as they campaign to ensure that
Democrats will win control of the House, without which their
contest for the majority leader post cannot take place.
“It’s being done on both sides,” said Rep. Bill Pascrell (D-N.J.),
a Murtha supporter, referring to the efforts to reach out to
candidates. “It would be remiss not to do it.”
In a Democratic House, freshman would number not fewer than 27
— at least 15 from previously Republican districts, plus as many
as 12 replacing Democrats who are retiring or running for higher
office. That bloc of new members, who lack the entrenched
loyalties of incumbents, is enticing to both campaigns.
Hoyer, the minority whip, has long been active with candidates,
traveling around the country on behalf of the Democratic
Congressional Campaign Committee (DCCC) to recruit promising
challengers, raise money, hold press events and mentor new
recruits through the ups and downs of the campaign season.
Hoyer has visited candidates in 31 districts this cycle, an
aide said, and directly contributed over $600,000 to candidates.
Murtha has traveled as well, hitting districts in Pennsylvania,
Ohio and New York, but he lacks the breadth and depth of
relationships Hoyer enjoys, said members and aides on both sides.
“It’s a slight advantage, yes,” Pascrell conceded. “Because [Hoyer]
has been involved in so many other elections, no one can argue
Steny’s status with candidates, [but] Jack is very well regarded
for his work on the committees. In the last five years, Jack has
emerged as an individual people will pay attention to because Iraq
and 9/11 is the subject at hand.”
Among current Democratic lawmakers, Murtha is undoubtedly a
giant, but to candidates, he is known largely for his outspoken
stance on Iraq, said Democratic sources.
“I am sure Mr. Murtha is a fine person, but Congressman Hoyer
came out to my district, held a fundraiser for me. He met with the
press. He’s been a mentor for questions, a coach, essentially a
father figure,” said a Democratic candidate in a competitive race
who asked to remain anonymous.
The candidate went on to suggest that Murtha’s position on Iraq
made him too polarizing for the district.
“I have an incredible respect for [Murtha’s] service
background, but in regard to the war, I’m trying to give my own
presentation.”
Rep. Mike Capuano (D-Mass.), a Murtha ally, downplayed the
influence of campaign work on leadership races.
“Does that personal contact matter? Yes. Does it translate into
votes? No. Candidates are thinking about their own races right
now, not this race.”
Capuano was confident of Murtha’s standing even before the new
members were counted, predicting that Murtha would win by a
“measurable degree.”
Capuano estimated that there were still 30 to 35 uncommitted
members in the race, 20 of whom had “vehemently opposed” the idea
of starting the contest before the election.
Rep. John Dingell (D-Mich.) took issue with Capuano’s
assessment.
“I thought that this campaign had been suspended,” he retorted.
“It seems there is a lot of over-confident talk being thrown
around while we should be concentrating on the November
elections.”
But Dingell’s doubts about conducting a race now didn’t prevent
him from throwing his support behind Hoyer.
“A majority of our caucus understands that Steny is the
majority leader we need to help lead us when we take back the
House,” he said.
If Murtha is to win, as Capuano contends, he must do so against
a tide of newly elected members who have been helped by Hoyer.
Many Democratic candidates running in swing districts are
centrists, and centrists have traditionally sided with Hoyer.
Rep. Mike Ross (D-Ark.), a Blue Dog who did not vote for Hoyer
in the race for whip several years ago, said he was backing Hoyer
now. He lauded the whip’s work with candidates.
“The phone calls he’s made, the trips around the country, the
people he knows and the people who know him will all help his
chances of being the next majority leader,” Ross said. “... How
many Democratic candidates has he not met? The answer is very few.
“I have not one bad word to say about Jack Murtha, but I’ve
seen Steny continue to work, working hard every year and I think
he’s earned the right.”
Still, Murtha has a formidable track record on leadership
races. He largely engineered Rep. Nancy Pelosi’s (D-Calif.) ascent
to minority leader and Rep. John Larson’s (D-Conn.) victory in the
race for caucus vice-chairman.
Asked whether Hoyer enjoyed an advantage among candidates,
Murtha said only, “We’ll see.”
Murtha has been picking and choosing his opportunities across
the country, at times taking a gamble in safe Democratic seats by
endorsing a candidate before the primary. He backed Mike Erlandson,
a Democratic candidate in Minnesota, before he lost to Keith
Ellison in the primary. In New York, he had better luck, holding a
town hall event for candidate Yvette Clarke shortly before she won
her primary.
“It was extraordinary,” said Clarke, who was doing a victory
tour around Capitol Hill yesterday. “We were gaining momentum at
that time and [the visit] just threw the campaign into overdrive.
That was significant. It wasn’t just an endorsement for
endorsement’s sake.”
Hoyer, the minority whip, called her after the primary to offer
his congratulations, but she knew little about him.
“I looked on the Internet afterwards and: Lo and behold!”
Clarke said she had no preference yet in the majority race, but
she was scheduled yesterday to meet with Murtha.